What have you been averaging for city driving? What kind of driver would you say that you are? Difference between Sport (18" wheels) and Limited? I believe larger wheels would hit mileage a bit. Please post if manual or automatic. Thanks!
What is surprising is how close the mileage on the sticker is compared to say an Outback and that car is so much larger and heavier. So I wonder if the real world driving for the Outback is very low (say low 20s or teens). I started my search with the Outback but then thought that I didn't really need that large of a car and the sticker price difference. Seems the 5-door Impreza would suit me fine.the difference between the 16 inch and 18 inch tires is 0.2" in diameter or 7 revolutions per mile. 17 to 18 is even closer, like exactly the same size based on the calculator i used. I assume this is so they dont need different speedometer/ecm calibrations based on wheel size. So i would say the tires themselves, the compound, tread, inflation levels, etc.. would be the larger factor than the actual wheel diameter.
But to answer your question, i have observed 22-25 city mpg with an auto premium with the 16" wheels. Thats not very percise since i have never hand calculated a tank of exclusively city driving, but based on the cars mpg computer thats what i got. given the 3-5% error in mileage the comp provides vs hand calculating.
My actual mileage for a full tank was just above 34 mpg(comp said 1.5 mpg better). But this was in all sub freezing temps. My truck gets 16-17 when its that cold but when it warms up its between 20.0-21.0 on the same commute so i assume the actual mileage i will get will be around 40 or greater when it warms up.What is surprising is how close the mileage on the sticker is compared to say an Outback and that car is so much larger and heavier. So I wonder if the real world driving for the Outback is very low (say low 20s or teens). I started my search with the Outback but then thought that I didn't really need that large of a car and the sticker price difference. Seems the 5-door Impreza would suit me fine.
Why is there such a big difference between the sport and premium?While I could see break-in explaining maybe 1-2mpg gains over time, as you said, I sure would not expect 8mpg lower than EPA due to break-in! Like I said, I may give it another few tanks and see how warmer weather helps - but right now it doesn't look like I could get 35mpg if I were on a flat straight highway with a strong tailwind.
From the data (fairly limited) on Fuelly, it doesn't look like anybody has gotten a tank over 32mpg! 2017 Subaru Impreza Sport MPG - Actual MPG from 5 2017 Subaru Impreza Sport owners